28-yr old nocturnal over@nal geekette Malaysian.

Yahoo! me msg me



previous 7 entries

Who is the richer? Jun.15

Bad breaks Jun.14

Sweet Suite plugs Jun. 6

Dr who? Jun. 4

Ashamed Jun. 4

Writing Soul Jun. 2

Scrapblog Jun. 2







Malaysia Blogsites List


Latest Articles by Zona Marie Tan

« Sorry, You don't look Malaysian | Main | midnite lily turns 6 & 28 »

Pan-Asian over non-celups

Headlines such as "Advertisers ordered to drop models with non-Malay faces" makes this simplistic ban feel even more outrageous, doesn't it?

One of the reasons why I'm writing another entry on this is obvious on two points. Some would say I take it personally because I am celup (of mixed parentage). But the other reason would be of a professional standpoint, which I'd like to validly share a little more backgrounder and opinion of.

I have worked with almost all your famous Malaysian Pan-Asian faces in the industry, and during the course of the productions with these few I had gotten to know their own personal stories and motivation to which I can empathize with. While their faces of indistinct racial identity exudes the media's idealism and fantasy, what we don't see is their personal conflict with identifying themselves to any one particular culture.

A number of artistes like former actress and Miss Malaysia/World '98/99 Lina Teoh, and Shamser for example, have been brought up in Australia to a culture almost completely foreign to their Asian parent/s. A culture which is a lot more vocal, and which also embraces creativity and freedom of expression, they grew up being vastly different to their Malaysian counterparts. Then there are also the few who spent their whole lives growing up in Malaysia but found themselves with a different outlook to life.

But for those who were born and brought up abroad, some would return to Malaysia in search of themselves or visit family and end up accidentally being scouted for the media. Some on the other hand, have actively tried in their own Western home country to break into the entertainment media scene but found they couldn't because they looked "too Asian". So where would they go? Prospects were of course (relatively) better in Malaysia. At least to build a portfolio of professional media experience, and then maybe try again "back home".

Where there is supply, there's a demand for these Pan-Asian personalities. Why do media producers seem to favour the celups over local faces? The obvious answer is we're all superficial, we enjoy looking at pretty faces; and unfortunately, our distorted perception of beauty is too skewed to the Caucasian flavour. Plus we hold Western brands in higher esteem anyway. There seems to be the common idea that being Western makes you superior. Hence, the media plays with this perception - the Pan-Asian look is the East meets West look - so why not hire them? They seem to define the best of both worlds anyway.

That's just for the print ads and TV commercials where you don't even hear these talents speak, where some of their personalities don't even matter. However, in Malaysia, because our industry is so small and racially segregated, to sustain their "rice bowl" they become multi-talents across media genres - in acting and hosting TV programmes. They're embraced further because they're more articulate. They are admittedly a bit more critical, analytical and outspoken compared to their non-celup counterparts. I'm not saying there are no non-celup talents who are of the same caliber, just that the choices are few and far in between.

Especially more baffling about this ban is knowing there are so many paradoxes in our own society over things like beauty pageants. Did you know that since the mid-90s Malay women are banned from participating in any beauty contests like the Miss World, Miss Universe pageants? They'll be taken to Syariah court if caught. Irony? Malaysia is represented in the International front by a non-Malay. So what happens when our Pan-Asian girls like Miss Malaysia/Universe '03 Elaine Daly gets banned from the media completely? We won't even get to see her on our own MSM, but the whole world will know she represents us. Does that make sense? Malaysia's definitely moving backwards.

If Datuk Zainuddin Maidin's concern is that there should be a balance in selecting the faces of our media, then it should be a restriction. Not an outright ban. What I'd predict for the future of Malaysian television? More Sunsilk tudung-clad girls type of TV commercials for sure. If that's any ad to baffle your senses, that's it. And guys, imagine - no more Hannah Tan. Even if she's 100% Malaysian.

Here's a funny anecdote that happened to me during a project I completed for the Tourism Ministry before I left. We were working on a video for Visit Malaysia 2007, to which the director's concept was to show the real people of Malaysia. He was obviously going for your average Mat, Ali and Ah Beng types to give the video a feel of our reality (in a polished setting, of course) and not the pretty talents so often used. What the tourism officer told us? Hesitantly, "We'd prefer if you used prettier talents. Since the video is marketed abroad."



Comments

The last line hit a nerve, ouch! Makes you wonder if these tourist will 'visit Bolehland' if we look like ourselves. Bolehland is sooo famous for 'putting up a good show' and leave suckers out to dry. We're more 'Shanghai' than the real Shanghai.

It is only the truth. Really, who would want to visit M'sia if the videos showed dark skinned, average looking girls? Part of Thailand's appeal is the exotic Thai beauty. Party of SIA's appeal are the pretty airstewardesses (even though a lot of them are from M'sia).

Datuk here is just shooting off words without thinking which is horrible for someone who is Minister of INFORMATION!

has any advert with models ever influenced you in your purchasing decision?

mob: put on a good show if they must. but at least let the people benefit from it...

mei: it's a human trait. you can deny it in media, or try to like our datuk is trying to do. but let see what good it does.

ront: are you asking me? media people are the exploiters of the consumers. the things i was taught in college. so i will have to say an obvious no. =P but i'd think the guys go for it no? heheh...

no lah....i never buy because of the ppl endorsing it.....i based my purchase on credibility of the product to do what its suppose to do...or the aesthetic of it.....definitely not who use it or who held it in his/her hand/legs/other nooks and cranny

Yeah, i agree.
not to ban them but restrict the intake.
We love pretty gals riteeee ?

Furthermore, please define "pure malay"..

Believe dat we are all mix ..
very special rojak culture..

Leave a braincell